• They Are So Young and BMW is About to Kill Them - Which Models Will BMW Send to the Guillotine to Save Cheddar?

Sentimentality flies out the window when the bottom line is in danger

LISTEN 13:15

There’s a glamorous side to the auto world that we often celebrate in world debuts, product launches, and concept car reveals. But as exciting as that side of the business is, the actual business of making money is about as ruthless and cutthroat as it gets. We don’t often see this aspect of the industry, but when it rears its ugly head, it can turn the fortunes of an automaker upside down without warning. Like most automakers, BMW’s bottom line is its number one priority. When that bottom line trends north, everyone goes home with a smile on their face. But what if that bottom line suddenly reverses course? Panic ensues and plans and projects, no matter how new, are scuttled and thrown directly into the trash bin. To be clear, BMW is still profitable; it’s just not as profitable as it would like to be, especially with heavy investments in hybridization and electrification draining most of its profits away. To keep its numbers from spiraling out of control, BMW is reportedly considering axing several models from its lineup, including a pair of models that have just been unveiled in the last couple of years. The cost-cutting measures come at a time when Bimmer is redirecting its attention and resources towards projects that will help it remain relevant in the next decade. It’s just that, by doing that, we’re likely going to have to say goodbye to some of the automaker’s current models, none more surprising, at least in my mind, than the new BMW Z4 and coupé and convertible versions of the BMW 8 Series.

BMW 2 Series Convertible Canceled

2015 BMW 2 Series Convertible High Resolution Exterior
- image 567862

On the surface, the BMW 2 Series Convertible has all the makings of a great ride. It’s fun to drive and it punches well above its weight when it comes to its amenities. So why is the 2 Series Convertible in the crosshairs of getting canceled? Sales, dear Watson. Sales. Some of it isn’t the 2er’s fault. BMW has so many investments in the pipeline that all the money it’s bleeding to fund those investments is eating into its profits. Canceling a few models helps mitigate that, even if it means getting rid of what is essentially a solid premium compact convertible. And if there’s anything the 2 Series Convertible can teach us, even great rides aren’t immune to the trash bin if they’re not turning in solid sales numbers.

That’s the biggest issue with the 2 Series Convertible.

Over in Europe, where the bulk of the 2 Series’ sales come from, the coupé and convertible versions have steadily declined in the first half of 2019 compared to sales numbers in the same time period a year before.

In the first five months of the current year, BMW has sold only 11,385 units of the 2 Series. That’s well below its 2018 pace when BMW sold 15,374 units of the 2 Series. I don’t have the sales split between the coupé and convertible versions of the 2 Series from 2018, but in 2017, the coupé outsold the convertible by a 2:1 ratio as 20,075 coupé models were sold compared to only 9,874 convertible units.

2015 BMW 2 Series Convertible High Resolution Exterior
- image 567869

Since the 2 Series isn’t a profitable vehicle for BMW to begin with, keeping the coupé and ditching the convertible makes a lot of sense if BMW wants to tighten its budget to fund more important investments. There will always be casualties when an automaker as big as BMW streamlines its budgets to the extent that it will for future projects and investments. The 2 Series Convertible is an easy scapegoat because, at the end of the day, it’s not really that important of a model to BMW.

Read our full review on the 2018 BMW 2 Series Convertible

Standard-wheelbase BMW 7 Series Canceled

They Are So Young and BMW is About to Kill Them - Which Models Will BMW Send to the Guillotine to Save Cheddar? Exterior
- image 815785

BMW has the same struggles as Mercedes-Benz and Audi these days. All three automakers struggle to make money on cars that sell under $40,000. It’s one of the reasons why the 2 Series Convertible is headed to death row, and while it’s still important to have a presence in these segments, models like the 1 Series, 2 Series, and even lower-spec trims of the 3 Series barely contribute anything to the automaker’s profit margins.

Instead, BMW makes its moolah off crossovers, SUVs, legacy models like the 3 Series sedan, and bigger sedans like the 5 Series.

The standard-wheelbase 7 Series has the credentials and chops to be included in this list, except that it isn’t because, well, most people who do buy the 7 Series prefer the long-wheelbase “limousine” version.

This is cannibalism at its finest. People see the same model presented in two different ways. Instead of “saving” a few thousands of dollars on the standard 7 Series, prospective buyers — most of whom are rich and can afford what most of us can’t — instead pay the extra to get the extra. That has left the standard-wheelbase 7 Series in a precarious position. Some people still buy it, but the volume isn’t enough to justify its existence, especially when there’s a bigger and better version that can be purchased for a small premium over the standard model’s sticker price.

They Are So Young and BMW is About to Kill Them - Which Models Will BMW Send to the Guillotine to Save Cheddar? Exterior
- image 815743

I’m positive that BMW had the best of intentions when it released the current-generation, standard-wheelbase 7 Series (G11) in 2015. It’s done its part to help BMW grab a decent chunk of the super-luxury sedan market, but times and, more importantly, priorities have changed. The standard-wheelbase 7 Series has become expendable enough that the long-wheelbase version can step up and occupy both sub-segments without missing a beat. It’s been a good run for the 7 Series G11, but its time has come. Not a lot of people will probably miss it, least of all BMW, which can use the money it would have otherwise used in building the sedan for its future investments in hybridization, electrification, and autonomous driving technology, among others.

BMW 740i specifications
Engine 3.0-liter BMW TwinPower Turbo inline 6-cylinder
Displacement 2,998 cc
Horsepower 335 @ 5500-6500
Torque (lb-ft @ rpm) 330 @ 1500-5200
Compression ratio (:1) 11
0 to 60 mph 5.3 seconds
Top Speed 130 mph

Read our full review on the 2020 BMW 7 Series

BMW 3 Series GT Canceled

2017 BMW 3 Series Gran Turismo High Resolution Exterior Wallpaper quality
- image 678224

This doesn’t come as a surprise anymore because no less than BMW CEO Harold Kruger announced a few months ago that “there would be no successor” to the current 3 Series Gran Turismo. You can point to lagging sales of the model as one of the key reasons behind its demise, but the 3 Series GT’s most critical flaw ironically came at the hands of BMW. As BMW executive pointe pointed out back in May, the 3 Series GT’s niche was “under pressure from SUVs” and that buyers “want to sit a little more upright” than what the 3 Series GT provided. The latter is particularly damning because it’s a clear miscalculation on the part of BMW’s designers.

The 3 Series GT also found itself in the crosshairs of buyer preference, particularly because the 3 Series also offered a four-door model, as well as an estate model.

Simply put, the 3 Series GT was model without a clear identity. It didn’t have the pedigree of the 3 Series dour-door and those who gave the GT a passing glance ultimately ended up choosing between the X1 or the X3. In any other time, the 3 Series GT could’ve worked, much like the 5 Series GT, which went on to evolve into the 6 Series. But the 3 Series GT never had the space to grow the way the 5 Series GT. It arrived at a time when the crossover and SUV craze was on the precipice of exploding and the model’s own identity crisis didn’t help its case, either.

2017 BMW 3 Series Gran Turismo High Resolution Exterior
- image 678192

Of all the models on this list, the BMW 3 Series GT is the least surprising to inevitably walk the plank. We all knew that it was on borrowed time. We know that it’s dead-car-walking. But the next two cars on this list? Whew! Those threw us for a loop!

BMW 3 Series GT specifications
BMW 320i Gran Turismo BMW 330i Gran Turismo BMW 340i Gran Turismo
Config/No of cyls/valves In-line/4/4 In-line/4/4 In-line/6/4
Effective capacity cc 1,998 1,998 2,998
Max output 184 HP @ 5,000 RPM 252 HP @ 5,200 RPM 326 HP @ 5,500 RPM
Max Torque 214 LB-FT @ 1,350–4,250 RPM 258 LB-FT @ 1,450–4,800 RPM 332 LB-FT @ 1,380–5,000 RPM
0–100 km/h (62 mph) 8.0 seconds 6.1 seconds 5.1 seconds
Top Speed km/h 230 km/h 250 km/h 250 km/h

Read our full review on the 2018 BMW 3 Series GT

BMW Z4 Canceled

2019 BMW Z4
- image 809475

Wait a second. The BMW Z4, the same car that BMW literally spent more than five years developing with Toyota and the same car that made its debut barely a year ago, is now in the chopping block? The Z4 has only been on sale for four months and just crossed the 1,000 sold units threshold less than two months ago, and it’s already getting its eulogy ready?

It’s absurd to imagine such a scenario if you look at it from the lens of these questions. But like everything else, context needs to be placed where it’s due, and it’s definitely due in this scenario. The BMW Z4 is not getting axed anytime soon. That much is clear. BMW spent too much time, money, and resources to develop the car only to ditch it before it can even celebrate its first anniversary in the market. The Z4 will have a full production cycle that could presumably last well into the next decade.

2019 BMW Z4
- image 809459

That’s not the issue here, though.

The issue here is that the Z4, and the next car on this list, is a perfect example of how quick the tides turn in the auto industry.

It’s especially true for a car that took almost seven years to develop. What was thought of as a great idea back in 2012 may not be a good idea in 2019 or even 2020 and beyond. But automakers like BMW spend the time, money, and the resources to develop a car like this. That’s not necessarily Bimmer’s fault, especially if the main objective is to create a performance machine that carries everything that BMW stands for. That’s the Z4 Roadster. It’s just that even the best-laid plans can go awry through no fault of the automaker if the auto industry undergoes a dramatic shift, not only in future ideologies but, more importantly, customer preference. You can say that BMW and the Z4 are victims of that significant shift, but instead of being stubborn about the hand it was dealt, BMW shifted its focus towards the future of the brand. And if the Z4 has no place in that future, then so be it. The roadster will enjoy a full life cycle, but if it’s true that BMW execs have decided on retiring the model, then it tells you that BMW is being very careful about where it spends its money next.

BMW Z4 specifications
BMW Z4 sDrive30i BMW Z4 M40i
Engine type B46 B58
Cylinders 4 6
Valves per cylinder 4 4
Stroke mm 94.6 94.6
Bore mm 82.0 82.0
Displacement cm³ 1,998 2,998
Compression rate :1 10.2 11.0
Engine power 255 HP @ 5,000 - 6,500 RPM 382 Hp @ 5,000 – 6,500 RPM
Engine torque 295 LB-FT @ 1,500-4,400 RPM 369 LB-FT @ 1,600 – 4,500 RPM
0 to 60 mph 5.2 seconds 3.9 seconds
Top speed 155 mph 155 mph

Read our full review on the 2019 BMW Z4

BMW 8 Series Canceled

2019 BMW 8 Series Exterior
- image 783867

The BMW Z4 Roadster wasn’t the only surprising model to be included in this rumored list. Turns out, the BMW 8 Series is also in there for possibly the same reasons as the Z4 Roadster. This one also sounds strange on paper, in part because BMW spent a great deal of time in giving the 8 Series a clear place in its lineup as its unquestioned flagship model. Now it seems that company execs are prepared to cut the legs off of the 8 Series by ditching the coupé and convertible models, leaving only the 8 Series Gran Coupe model to carry the mantle for the nameplate.

That’s refreshing to hear.

At least the 8 Series nameplate will live on, but with fewer versions than BMW expected it would have.

And if you take the time to think about this decision, it doesn’t sound as strange as a lot of people are making it out to be. Consider this: the 8 Series Convertible has always been a token addition to the nameplate. It was a way for BMW to present the 8 Series in as many different versions as it can with the hope that each version would gain sales traction in what is already considered a niche market in the first place. I can make a case for the BMW 8 Series Coupe if it’s a standalone model. But the presence of the 8 Series Gran Coupe does make the coupé redundant, doesn’t it? As far as the 8 Series convertible goes, is there a place for it in the 8 Series lineup? Maybe for some people, the idea of being seen in an 8 Series is enough reason to spend at least $120,000 on a car, but it doesn’t work for BMW at the price it’s developing the model when it can spend its resources on shaping its future identity as an automaker.

2019 BMW 8 Series Exterior
- image 783859

I understand that all these cancellations are largely due to company revenue not being where it is, or at least where BMW’s bigwigs expected it to be. In a perfect world, BMW would keep all these models going because they’re helping make the automaker more profitable. But we don’t live in a perfect world. We live in a world where BMW’s share prices in Europe have fallen from €122 ($137) in 2015 to €65 ($73) this year. We live in a world where earnings of the company’s car division dropped 22 percent from its numbers the year before. We also live in a world where BMW, like every other automaker, has to account for an unsettled global economy that’s being weighed down by a looming trade war between the US and China. And through all that, the German automaker still has to push forward with its major investments for the future, even if it comes at the cost of putting pressure on the company’s overall budget. The best way to ease some of these stress points is to save money where it can, and one way to do that is dropping models that contribute little to nothing to the company’s bottom line.

BMW 8 Series specifications
Engine type N63B44T3
Cylinders 8
Valves per cylinder 4
Stroke 88.3 mm
Bore 89.0 mm
Displacement 4,395 cm³
Compression rate :1 10.5
Engine power 523 HP @ 5,500 - 6,000 RPM
Engine torque 553 LB-FT @ 1,800-4,600 RPM
Transmission type 8HP76 Sport
Transmission type automatic
0-60 mph 3.6 seconds
Top speed 155 mph

Read our full review on the BMW 8 Series

Source: Automobile Mag

Kirby Garlitos
Kirby Garlitos
Automotive Aftermarket Expert - kirby@topspeed.com
Kirby’s first exposure into the world of automobiles happened when he caught Knight Rider on television as a five-year old boy. David Hasselhoff didn’t leave much of an impression on him (that happened later on in Baywatch), but KITT certainly did. To this day, Kirby remains convinced that he will one day own a car with the same ‘spirit’ as the original KITT (not the 2008 monstrosity). He doesn't know when that will be, but until then, he’s committed to expressing his love for KITT, and all cars for that matter, here at TopSpeed.  Read full bio
About the author
What do you think?
Show Comments
Car Finder: