The Greatest Cars Deprived Of A Manual Transmission - story fullscreen Fullscreen

The Greatest Cars Deprived Of A Manual Transmission

These cars deserved to have the option of a manual transmission but never got It

LISTEN 14:15

By now, manufacturers (at least mainstream ones) have made it clear that the days of the manual gearbox are coming to an end. Shifting the gears yourself and working a third pedal will eventually become a lost art. Although we see it mainly in modern cars, this process actually started a while ago and some cars (or specific versions of them) that should have come with a manual gearbox were deprived of it.

Ferrari F430 Scuderia

2008 Ferrari F430 Scuderia
- image 204699

The Ferrari F430 actually came with two gearbox options. One of them was a manual, while the other was an “F1” robotized manual. Apparently, the marketing gimmick worked, since most F430 buyers ordered the robotized gearbox, instead of the manual one, which also has a gated shifter (shame on you).

The F430 Scuderia was a lighter, more powerful version of the normal F430 and was much more track-focused. It was 220 pounds (100 kg) lighter and developed 510 horsepower instead of 483 from the 4.3-liter flat-plane V-8. Sadly, the Scuderia never had the option of a manual gearbox and only came with the “F1” transmission.

2008 Ferrari F430 Scuderia
- image 198999

You might argue that automatic shaves off valuable tenths of a second from your lap time, but back when the Ferrari 430 came out, automatic gearboxes were not as advanced and certainly not as quick as today’s units. Back then, a talented driver could out-shift an automatic. Because of this, the 430 Scuderia would have been perfectly fine with a gated, six-speed manual.

Read our full review on the Ferrari F430 Scuderia

BMW M3 CSL E46

The Greatest Cars Deprived Of A Manual Transmission
- image 1020133
BMW M3 CSL E46
The CSL was 386 lbs lighter than the standard M3 and made 360 instead of 338 hp

This one is kind of obvious, which is all the more reason it should be on the list. The M3 has always been the benchmark of the segment and the E46 M3, in particular, is still regarded, by many, as the ultimate M3 in terms of driving dynamics and overall feel.

In 2003, BMW came up with a more hardcore version of the E46 M3 – the M3 CSL (Coupe Sport Light). It was lighter (386 pounds/175 kg less), stiffer, and more powerful than the standard M3.

Its 3.2-liter S54 inline-six engine now made 360 horsepower and 273 pound-feet (370 Nm).

The CSL improved upon what was already an exceptional driver’s machine.

The Greatest Cars Deprived Of A Manual Transmission
- image 1020135
One of the most praised driver’s cars got one of the most hated gearboxes
Unlike the standard M3 E46, the CSL only came with the SMG rototized manual.

And then, BMW gave it the sloppy six-speed SMG II gearbox – another robotized manual that didn’t come with a third pedal. To add insult to the injury, they even made the shifter look like it’s on a manual gearbox.

Read our full review on the BMW M3 CSL E46

Alfa Romeo 8C

2007 Alfa Romeo 8C Competizione
- image 100848

The Alfa Romeo 8C will go down in history as one of the most beautiful cars ever made. The effortlessly gorgeous looks were tastefully paired with a Maserati-derived 4.7-liter, naturally-aspirated V-8 that makes 450 horsepower and 347 pound-feet (470 Nm), which allows for a 4.2-second sprint to 60 mph (97 km/h).

2007 Alfa Romeo 8C Competizione
- image 100835

Add the fact that most of the car was made out of carbon fiber and had a limited-slip differential in the back and you would think Alfa has made the perfect driver’s car. Sadly, that’s not the case, because the whole package is ruined by a six-speed, you guessed it, robotized manual gearbox. Yes, “in true Alfa tradition”, it’s mounted in the back, but it simply isn’t a proper manual gearbox.

Read our full review on the Alfa Romeo 8C

Toyota GR Supra

The Greatest Cars Deprived Of A Manual Transmission
- image 838458
Toyota GR Supra
Forget the underpinnings and design. The Supra already proved to be very capable

The GR Supra is one of the more recent cars on the list. In the case of the A90 Supra, the BMW-derived platform and engine have undergone some “optimizations”, courtesy of Toyota Gazoo Racing. Whether that’s the case or not, it’s obvious that the car is a capable performer. As we’ve seen in more than a few drag races, the Supra is able to keep up and beat much more powerful cars.

2020 Toyota Supra
- image 838460

Part of the credit has to go to the ZF eight-speed automatic, which rivals some dual-clutch transmissions in terms of shift times.

Regardless, all previous generations of the Toyota Supra gave you an option between a manual and an automatic – something the new one does not give you.

Granted, the new Supra would have been slower, but it may have been a more engaging driver’s car.

Read our full review on the Toyota GR Supra

Alpine A110

2017 Renault Alpine A110 Exterior
- image 909713

Another iconic name that recently made a comeback is the Alpine A110. The retro-inspired rear-engine, rear-wheel-drive coupe is a spiritual successor to the 1961 Alpine A110. They’ve done as good of a job as possible to replicate the 1960s design, given all current “safety regulations” that state how high the headlights should be, how big the mirrors need to be, and other pointless crap.

Regardless, the new Alpine also replicates the original’s formula when it comes to driving dynamics, for the most part at least.

Like its forefather, its lightweight gives the new A110 incredible performance, pound for pound.

Even in its base form, the 1.8-liter turbo-four makes 252 horsepower and 236 pound-feet (320 Nm), which is enough to propel the 2,381-pound (1,080 kg) Alpine to 60 mph (97 km/h) in 4.4 seconds.

2017 Renault Alpine A110 Exterior
- image 909639

That said, the only thing the new A110 lacks compared to the original is a manual gearbox. The DCT does a great job at propelling the car, but a lightweight sports car like that, especially a retro-inspired one, needs to have the option of a good-old manual transmission.

Read our full review on the Alpine A110

Alfa Romeo 4C

2014 Alfa Romeo 4C High Resolution Exterior
- image 523905

The small mid-engine Alfa is even lighter than the Alpine A110, at just 1,973 pounds (895 kg). Because of this, 240 horsepower and 258 pound-feet (350 Nm) from the 1.75-liter turbo-four are enough to rocket the small Alfa to 60 mph (97 km/h) in just 4.3 seconds. Power, of course, goes to the rear axle, just like in a Lotus Elise.

Sadly, unlike the Lotus, which comes as a manual-only, Alfa Romeo only gives you a six-speed dual-clutch automatic. Another missed opportunity Alfa and, sadly, not the last on this list.

Read our full review on the Alfa Romeo 4C

Buick GNX (1987)

The Greatest Cars Deprived Of A Manual Transmission
- image 1020132
Buick GNX
Buick decided to end production of the Regal with a bang

I almost wanted to refrain from saying that “If Darth Vader had a car, this would be it”, since pretty much everyone else does, but it’s just too accurate.

In its last year of production, the boxy Buick, mostly associated with old people, received extensive modifications from McLaren USA.

The Grand National Experimental (GNX) stood out from the rest with a completely murdered-out look (it was all black), which made it look like Darth Vader’s helmet, hence the nickname. More importantly, the 3.8-liter turbocharged V-6 was tuned to make 276 horsepower (officially). The car reportedly made just over 300, but that’s a topic for another time.

The Greatest Cars Deprived Of A Manual Transmission
- image 1020134
Faster than a Corvette C4, despite the 4-speed auto
Nicknamed "Darth Vader’s car", the GNX was briefly the quickest car to 60 mph in the world

The torque is strong with this one, as it also makes 360 pound-feet (488 Nm). This helps the big black Buick reach 0-60 mph (97 km/h) in a Corvette-thrashing 4.6 seconds, on its way to a 13.4-second Quarter-mile time. Sadly, Darth Vader’s car only came with a four-speed automatic. I guess there are no manual gearboxes when you turn to the dark side.

Alfa Romeo Giulia QV (post-2018)

2017 Alfa Romeo Giulia Quadrifoglio High Resolution Exterior
- image 656146

In 2015, Alfa Romeo brought back another old name – the Giulia. It came back as a stylish sporty sedan and it seemed like all is well, as even the base trims were fun to drive. Of course, the Giulia Quadrofoglio was the real threat with its 2.9-liter twin-turbo engine, which definitely isn’t Ferrari-derived (wink). It makes 510 horsepower and 443 pound-feet (600 Nm), which allows for a 3.8-second time to 60 mph (97 km/h).

2017 Alfa Romeo Giulia Quadrifoglio High Resolution Exterior
- image 656135

Both the lesser versions and the QV could be had with a six-speed manual or a ZF eight-speed automatic.

Sadly, after 2018, the option of a manual was removed, leaving only the eight-speed auto.

Granted, the ZF unit is very capable and definitely quicker than a manual, but unlike the GTAm, the Quadrofoglio is not an all-out track monster, where every tenth of a second counts. Instead, the QV is more of a grand tourer, which is why removing the option of a manual gearbox is not fully justified.

Read our full review on the Alfa Romeo Giulia QV

Jaguar F-Type R

The Greatest Cars Deprived Of A Manual Transmission Exterior
- image 874478
Jaguar F-Type
Until 2016, you could get "the British Viper" with a V-8, RWD, and a manual

The Jaguar F-Type is the spiritual successor to the gorgeous E-Type and earlier, pre-facelift models, in particular, made it very obvious. Of course, things changed a bit with the facelift, where the rounded headlights were replaced by thin ones that made it look like a squinting house cat that just smelled its owner’s socks.

Do you know what else they dropped? The manual gearbox. Until 2016, you could get even the most powerful version of the F-Type with a good, old-fashioned six-speed manual, provided by ZF. Meanwhile, the 5.0-liter supercharged V-8 pumped out 550 horsepower and 502 pound-feet (680 Nm).

The Greatest Cars Deprived Of A Manual Transmission Exterior
- image 874479
No more manual or RWD-only for the V-8
The car was a handful, which is why all later V-8 models came with a ZF 8-speed auto and AWD only

Back then, you could also get this fire-breathing wildcat with a rear-wheel-drive only, which required balls of steel. Some even started calling it “the British Viper”, so that should tell you enough. Fast-forward to nowadays and the F-Type R has gained a bit of power – now 570 horsepower. However, you can no longer buy a supercharged V-8 F-Type with a manual and rear-wheel drive only.

Read our full review on the Jaguar F-Type R

Chevrolet Camaro 350 (1987)

The Greatest Cars Deprived Of A Manual Transmission
- image 1020138
Chevrolet Camaro IROC-Z 350
Unlike the lesser versions with anemic engines, the top-of-the-line 350 V-8 never got to partner up with a manual

The third-generation Camaro combined a lot of good and bad aspects. On one side, it was praised for its handling and looks when it came out, but on the other, its power output was pathetic. Although that was due to the performance-strangling emissions regulations, which were still in effect in the 1980s, the Camaro 350’s 5.7-liter V-8 only developed 220 horsepower (240 with the twin-cat exhaust) at 4,200 RPM and 320 pound-feet at 3,200 RPM.

That said, the car still managed a respectable-for-the-time 0 to 60 mph (97 km/h) time of 6.4 seconds and a top speed of 146 mph (235 km/h). However, the biggest drawback was the gearbox. While lesser variants (which had 15 horsepower less) could be had with a manual gearbox, the 350 only came with a Turbo Hydraulic THM 700-R4, four-speed automatic. Earlier models even had a three-speed auto.

Top 10 Cheapest Muscle Cars
- image 896102

Of course, nowadays, it’s easier than ever to do an LS swap with a Tremec T56 manual and all will be right in the world. But the fact remains that the third-generation Camaro 350 never came with a manual out of the box.

Subaru SVX

2017 Subaru SVX High Resolution Exterior
- image 555531

We all know about the legendary 1990s Japanese sports cars and how they took over the tuner car scene. But while cars like the Skyline, Supra, RX-7, and NSX stole the show, others weren’t as lucky.

Among the more obscure Japanese cars of that era is the Subaru SVX, which was a perfect example that Subaru used to make some really quirky vehicles.

The car had a lot of cool features, such as McLaren F1-style windows that opened partially. It also came with a 3.3-liter flat-six that makes 233 horsepower and 228 pound-feet (309 Nm). According to a 1991 review by Automobile Magazine, the engine sounded better than a Porsche and ran as smooth as a Lexus. They also said that the car handled like a German sports car and praised the Giugiaro-designed bodywork.

2017 Subaru SVX Exterior
- image 555719
1989 Subaru SVX Concept

Sadly, the car only came with a four-speed automatic gearbox. At least, in typical Subaru fashion, it came with all-wheel drive. Despite the gearbox, the coupe still managed a 6.8-second sprint to 60 mph (97 km/h) and was capable of 155 mph (250 km/h). The SVX was meant to be more of a grand-tourer than a canyon carver, but a manual would have certainly made the car more popular.

Read our full review on the Subaru SVX

Dim Angelov
Dim Angelov
Born in 1992, I come from a family of motoring enthusiasts. My passion for cars was awoken at the age of six, when I saw a Lamborghini Diablo SV in a magazine. After high school I earned a master’s degree in marketing and a Master of Arts in Media and Communications. Over the years, I’ve practiced and become skilled in precision driving and to date have test driven more than 250 cars across the globe. Over the years, I’ve picked up basic mechanical knowledge and have even taken part in the restoration of a 1964 Jaguar E-Type and an Alfa Romeo Giulia Sprint. Lately, I’ve taken a fancy to automotive photography, and while modern cars are my primary passion, I also have a love for Asian Martial Arts, swimming, war history, craft beer, historical weapons, and car restoration. In time, I plan my own classic car restoration and hope to earn my racing certificate, after which I expect to establish my own racing team.  Read full bio
About the author
What do you think?
Show Comments
Car Finder: