Summary

• Electric vehicles offer a promising future with fewer problematic parts, yet real-world data shows issues with batteries and charging systems.
• Consumer Reports ranks the 2024 Hyundai Ioniq 6 as a top electric car choice for its energetic acceleration, quiet cabin, and fast-charging ability.
• While EVs like the 2024 Mercedes-Benz EQE offer luxury and performance, predicted reliability ratings suggest potential issues with certain models.

When buying a new car, you first want to know if it is reliable. Real human experience can give you valuable insight into what to expect. Like every other year, Consumer Reports has issued a list of the most reliable electric cars, and, the list has changed a lot compared to the previous year. In a way, though, that is to be expected because as EVs age, consumers will have a little more experience with their vehicles. If any problems come to the surface, that is when it will show up. As the old saying goes, "Time will tell," and in this case, it most certainly will.

In theory, electric vehicles should be much more reliable because they are missing many problematic parts associated with ICE-powered vehicles, like the transmission, ignition, fuel systems, valvetrains, and exhaust system, among many other things. In reality, however, EVs have just as many, if not more, problems than gasoline-powered or hybrid models. Owners of electric cars have reported issues with the battery packs, charging, electric drive motors, and heating and cooling systems. Here's a list of 15 electric vehicles ranked by Consumer Reports according to the issues reported by owners.

UPDATE: 2024/04/17 08:30 EST BY ANIEBIET INYANG NTUI

To ensure our readers have access to the most up-to-date information, this article on the most reliable electric vehicles (EVs) has been comprehensively revised for 2024. This update reflects Consumer Reports' latest ratings.

In order to give you the most up-to-date and accurate information possible, the data used to compile this article was sourced from Consumer Reports, the various manufacturers and other reliable sources such as CarBuzz and HotCars.

TL;DR: Most Reliable Electric Cars According To Consumer Reports

(Data sourced from Consumer Reports and respective automakers)

1 2024 Hyundai Ioniq 6 - 83/100

Starting Price: $37,500

According to Consumer Reports, the 2024 Hyundai Ioniq 6 stands out as a compelling choice in the electric car market, earning its recommendation and ranking "#1 out of 5" in the category. It achieved an "impressive" overall score of 83 out of 100. Consumer Reports highlights several strengths of the Ioniq 6. Drivers are said to enjoy the energetic acceleration and responsive handling. The cabin is praised for its quietness, contributing to a comfortable driving experience. Additionally, the Ioniq 6 boasts impressive fast-charging capability using DC chargers, convenient for long trips or those who prefer quicker charging options.

2024 Hyundai Ioniq 6 Performance Specifications

(Specs sourced from Hyundai)

Key Metrics

• Road Test: 84 out of 100
• Predicted Reliability: 70 out of 100
• Predicted Owner Satisfaction: 5 out of 5

While Consumer Reports identified some drawbacks, they don't diminish the Ioniq 6's overall appeal. The control layout for windows and mirrors was found to be awkward, and the trunk space is on the smaller side compared to some competitors.

Owner Satisfaction Ratings

• Driving Experience: 90 out of 100
• Comfort: 83 out of 100
• Value: 35 out of 100

Consumer Reports (CR) gathers data on vehicle satisfaction through its annual survey. This survey includes responses from over half a million vehicle owners. A key metric is whether respondents would “definitely buy or lease the same model” again.

2 2024 BMW i4 - 83/100

Starting Price: $52,200

Consumer Reports considers the 2024 BMW i4 as a compelling choice in the electric luxury car segment, awarding it their recommendation and a ranking of "#1 out of 7 electric luxury cars" tested. It achieved a very impressive overall score of 83 out of 100. According to Consumer Reports, the i4 excels in capturing the essence of a BMW – a thrilling driving experience. They praise the smooth power delivery, quick acceleration, and sharp handling that live up to BMW's reputation. The i4's comfortable front seats, hushed interior, and high-quality cabin materials further contribute to its impressive road test score of 91 out of 100.

2024 BMW i4 Performance Specifications

(Specs sourced from BMW and the EPA)

Key Metrics

• Road Test: 91 out of 100
• Predicted Reliability: 60 out of 100
• Predicted Owner Satisfaction: 4 out of 5

However, Consumer Reports also identified some drawbacks to consider. The rear seat is cramped, offering limited space for passengers. Additionally, the i4's control layout was found to be complicated, potentially requiring more time to get accustomed to.

Owner Satisfaction Ratings

• Driving Experience: 96 out of 100
• Comfort: 77 out of 100
• Value: 35 out of 100

3 2024 Kia EV6 - 77/100

Starting Price: $42,600

Consumer Reports ranks the 2024 Kia EV6 as the "#1 electric SUV" out of 14 models tested. It achieved a very impressive overall score of 77 out of 100. According to Consumer Reports, the EV6 stands out for its well-rounded performance. They praise its exciting driving dynamics, including impressive acceleration, agile handling, and a quiet cabin. The EV6 also benefits from a comfortable ride and the ability to rapidly charge using DC fast chargers.

2024 Kia EV6 Performance Specifications

(Specs sourced from Kia)

Key Metrics

• Road Test: 78 out of 100
• Predicted Reliability: 66 out of 100
• Predicted Owner Satisfaction: 4 out of 5

However, Consumer Reports also identified some ergonomic drawbacks. The EV6 has limited outward visibility due to the design of the side and rear windows. Additionally, the exterior door handles were found to be awkward to use, and the climate and media controls are split in a way that may require more time to get accustomed to.

Owner Satisfaction Ratings

• Driving Experience: 92 out of 100
• Comfort: 85 out of 100
• Value: 31 out of 100

4 2024 Porsche Taycan - 76/100

Starting Price: $52,200

Consumer Reports acknowledges the 2024 Porsche Taycan as a strong contender in the electric luxury car segment, awarding it a spot as "#2 out of 7 electric luxury cars" they tested. It achieved an overall score of 76 out of 100. According to Consumer Reports, the Taycan excels at preserving the Porsche essence while transitioning to electric power. They particularly commend how well the Taycan retains the brand's DNA in terms of driving performance, handling agility, ride comfort, and "exceptional" craftsmanship.

2024 Porsche Taycan Performance Specifications

(Specs sourced from Porsche and the EPA)

Key Metrics

• Road Test: 78 out of 100
• Predicted Reliability: 66 out of 100
• Predicted Owner Satisfaction: 4 out of 5

However, Consumer Reports also identified some areas for improvement. The control layout was found to be complex and might require a steeper learning curve. Additionally, the Taycan's outward visibility is reported to be less than ideal. Consumer Reports does not have predicted owner satisfaction data yet, as the 2024 Taycan is a new model.

There have been two recent recalls by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) on the 2024 Porsche Taycan that both involve the electrical system and potential fire risks. The most recent recall, issued in March 2024, addresses a potential for a short circuit within the high-voltage battery that could lead to a fire. An earlier recall, from December 2023, identified a risk of overheating in the outlet or charging cable when using the industrial 220V/240V plug at the 100% charge setting.

5 2024 Kia Niro Electric - 71/100

Starting Price: $39,600

Consumer Reports considers the 2024 Kia Niro Electric a compelling option in the electric car segment, awarding it a spot as the "#2 out of 5 electric cars" they tested. The Niro Electric achieved an overall score of 71 out of 100. According to Consumer Reports, the Niro Electric stands out for its impressive value proposition. It boasts a spacious interior with hatchback functionality that rivals some small SUVs.

The driving experience is also enjoyable, with Consumer Reports praising the Niro Electric's zippy acceleration, agile handling, and decent ride comfort. An additional perk is the Niro Electric's impressive driving range of 255 miles according to the EPA, which surpasses even some pricier electric vehicles. However, during their own 70-mph highway range test, Consumer Reports only achieved 239 miles.

2024 Kia Niro Electric Performance Specifications

(Specs sourced from Kia and the EPA)

Key Metrics

• Road Test: 76 out of 100
• Predicted Reliability: 51 out of 100
• Predicted Owner Satisfaction: 4 out of 5

However, Consumer Reports also identified some limitations. All-wheel drive is not available in the Niro Electric, which may be a drawback for some drivers, especially in wintery climates. The Niro Electric also inherits the new Kia split-use climate and media control panel, which Consumer Reports finds to be annoying to use. Additionally, rearward and side visibility is hampered by the car's design.

Owner Satisfaction Ratings

• Driving Experience: 91 out of 100
• Comfort: 88 out of 100
• Value: 44 out of 100

6 2024 Nissan Ariya - 70/100

Starting Price: $39,590

Consumer Reports considers the 2024 Nissan Ariya a strong contender in the electric SUV segment, awarding it a spot as "#2 out of 7 electric SUVs" they tested. The Ariya achieved an overall score of 70 out of 100. According to Consumer Reports, the Ariya delivers on some key aspects that electric car drivers look for. It boasts a desirable size for a small SUV, offering an elevated driving position and ample cargo space. The Ariya also proves to be quick, quiet, and roomy inside, with a decent driving range of 255 miles according to the EPA.

Nissan Ariya Powertrain Specs

(Specs sourced from Nissan)

Key Metrics

• Road Test: 70 out of 100
• Predicted Reliability: 62 out of 100
• Predicted Owner Satisfaction: 4 out of 5

However, Consumer Reports also identified some ergonomic quirks. The unplugging process requires extra steps compared to other EVs, and the brake pedal has a grabby feel that some drivers may find unpleasant. Additionally, the onboard charger is considered to be weak, potentially leading to longer charging times at home.

Owner Satisfaction Ratings

• Driving Experience: 89 out of 100
• Comfort: 83 out of 100
• Value: 39 out of 100

7 2024 Ford Mustang Mach-E​​ - 70/100

Starting Price: $39,995

Consumer Reports ranks the 2024 Ford Mustang Mach-E as a strong contender in the electric SUV segment, awarding it "#3 out of 7 electric SUVs" they tested. It achieved an overall score of 70 out of 100. According to Consumer Reports, the Mustang Mach-E stands out for its ability to blend performance with practicality. It offers impressive acceleration and handling, making it one of the more enjoyable electric vehicles to drive. The Mustang Mach-E also boasts a quiet cabin and the option for all-wheel drive, enhancing its appeal in various weather conditions.

2024 Ford Mustang Mach-E Performance Specifications

(Specs sourced from Ford and the EPA)

Key Metrics

• Road Test: 74 out of 100
• Predicted Reliability: 45 out of 100
• Predicted Owner Satisfaction: 4 out of 5

Consumer Reports again identified some ergonomic drawbacks. The door handles require extra attention to open, and the control layout may take some time to get accustomed to.

Owner Satisfaction Ratings

• Driving Experience: 93 out of 100
• Comfort: 74 out of 100
• Value: 37 out of 100

8 2024 Lucid Air - 69/100

Starting Price: $77,400

Consumer Reports considers the 2024 Lucid Air a strong contender in the electric luxury car segment, awarding it "#3 out of 7 electric luxury cars" they tested. The Air achieved an overall score of 69 out of 100. According to Consumer Reports, the Lucid Air boasts impressive qualities that are sure to turn heads.

With its sleek, aerodynamic design, the Air offers a luxurious feel and exceptional performance. It boasts a class-leading driving range of 385 miles according to the EPA, making it ideal for long journeys. The Air also provides a spacious and comfortable cabin, especially for rear-seat passengers. Consumer Reports testers were particularly impressed by the Air's blistering acceleration, sharp handling, and impressive braking distances.

2024 Lucid Air Performance Specifications

(Specs sourced from Lucid)

Key Metrics

• Road Test: 94 out of 100
• Predicted Reliability: 31 out of 100
• Predicted Owner Satisfaction: 3 out of 5

However, Consumer Reports also identified some drawbacks that may be a concern for some drivers. The Lucid Air is a product from a new automaker, and Consumer Reports acknowledges the inherent risk associated with such a purchase in terms of service and reliability with issues like electric motor whine. The Air also has some ergonomic shortcomings. The controls can be confusing to use, outward visibility is hampered by the design, and wind noise can be intrusive at times.

Owner Satisfaction Ratings

• Driving Experience: 93 out of 100
• Comfort: 85 out of 100
• Value: 33 out of 100

9 2024 Hyundai Ioniq 5 - 69/100

Starting Price: $41,800

Consumer Reports ranks the 2024 Hyundai Ioniq 5 as a strong contender in the electric SUV segment, awarding it "#4 out of 7 electric SUVs" they tested. It achieved an overall score of 67 out of 100. According to Consumer Reports, the Ioniq 5 stands out for its well-rounded performance and functionality. It delivers impressive acceleration and agile handling, rivaling some sport sedans. The ride quality is comfortable, and the interior offers ample space for passengers and cargo.

Consumer Reports also praises the Ioniq 5's 800-volt architecture, which allows for significantly faster DC fast-charging compared to other EVs on the market. This can be a major perk for long trips, reducing charging downtime.

2024 Hyundai Ioniq 5 Performance Specifications

(Specs sourced from Hyundai)

Key Metrics

• Road Test: 86 out of 100
• Predicted Reliability: 33 out of 100
• Predicted Owner Satisfaction: 4 out of 5

However, Consumer Reports also identified a potential concern. The Ioniq 5 is a new model, and Consumer Reports predicts it to have below-average reliability.

Owner Satisfaction Ratings

• Driving Experience: 94 out of 100
• Comfort: 87 out of 100
• Value: 31 out of 100

10 2024 Tesla Model S - 63/100

Starting Price: $74,990

Consumer Reports positions the 2024 Tesla Model S as a strong contender in the electric luxury car segment, awarding it #4 out of 7 electric luxury cars they tested. The Model S achieved an overall score of 63 out of 100. According to Consumer Reports, the Model S boasts some undeniable strengths.

It offers one of the longest driving ranges among all-electric vehicles, making it ideal for long journeys. It also delivers impressive acceleration and braking power, and the cabin is quiet and comfortable during operation. The hatchback design provides a versatile cargo area, enhancing practicality.

2024 Tesla Model S Powertrain Specs

(Specs sourced from Tesla)

Key Metrics

• Road Test: 86 out of 100
• Predicted Reliability: 30 out of 100
• Predicted Owner Satisfaction: 4 out of 5

However, Consumer Reports also identified some drawbacks that may be a concern for some drivers. Tesla's minimalist interior design may not be for everyone, and the new yoke steering wheel option is singled out for criticism due to its awkward shape and compromised usability. Additionally, the Model S, like other Teslas, lacks compatibility with Android Auto or Apple CarPlay, which are popular smartphone integration features offered by many competitors.

Owner Satisfaction Ratings

• Driving Experience: 96 out of 100
• Comfort: 78 out of 100
• Value: 42 out of 100

11 2024 Toyota bZ4X - 62/100

Starting Price: $43,070

Consumer Reports considers the 2024 Toyota bZ4X a decent option in the electric SUV segment, ranking it "#5 out of 7 electric SUVs" they tested. The bZ4X achieved an overall score of 62 out of 100. According to Consumer Reports, the bZ4X offers some positive attributes. It delivers a peppy driving experience with quick acceleration and agile handling, making it enjoyable to maneuver. Consumer Reports also praises the comfortable interior.

2024 Toyota bZ4X Powertrain Specifications

(Specs sourced from Toyota)

Key Metrics

• Road Test: 67 out of 100
• Predicted Reliability: 47 out of 100
• Predicted Owner Satisfaction: 2 out of 5

One of the major shortcomings identified by Consumer Reports is the limited driving range compared to other electric SUVs on the market. The bZ4X only offers a maximum of 220 miles according to the EPA, which may not be suitable for everyone's needs. Additionally, the charging speed is considered slow. Consumer Reports also criticizes the bZ4X's infotainment system, which lacks features specifically designed for electric vehicles. The lack of a glove box is another curious design choice.

Owner Satisfaction Ratings

• Driving Experience: 96 out of 100
• Comfort: 77 out of 100
• Value: 35 out of 100

12 2024 Subaru Solterra - 62/100

Starting Price: $44,995

Consumer Reports positions the 2024 Subaru Solterra as an average contender in the electric SUV segment, awarding it "#6 out of 7 electric SUVs" they tested. The Solterra achieved an overall score of 62 out of 100. According to Consumer Reports, the Solterra offers a decent driving experience. It accelerates quickly and handles well, making it enjoyable to maneuver. The cabin is also spacious and comfortable. These aspects are important for everyday driving.

2024 Subaru Solterra Powertrain Specifications

(Specs sourced from Subaru)

Key Metrics

• Road Test: 67 out of 100
• Predicted Reliability: 47 out of 100
• Predicted Owner Satisfaction: 2 out of 5

However, Consumer Reports identifies some shortcomings that may be significant for potential buyers. One of the major drawbacks is the limited driving range compared to other electric SUVs on the market. The Solterra only offers a maximum of 220 miles according to the EPA, which may not be suitable for everyone's needs. Additionally, charging times are considered slow. Consumer Reports also criticizes the Solterra's infotainment system, which lacks features specifically designed for electric vehicles. The lack of a glove box is another curious design choice.

Owner Satisfaction Ratings

• Driving Experience: 67 out of 100
• Comfort: 47 out of 100
• Value: 35 out of 100

13 2024 Mercedes-Benz EQE - 59/100

Starting Price: $74,900

Consumer Reports cautions that the 2024 Mercedes-Benz EQE may not be the most reliable choice. They awarded the EQE an overall score of 59 out of 100, with a below-average predicted reliability rating of 23 out of 100. This prediction is based on Consumer Reports' data on similar Mercedes-Benz models and the brand's overall reliability record. It's important to note that this is a prediction, and individual vehicles may experience varying levels of reliability. Consumer Reports points to the fact that the 2024 Mercedes-Benz EQE has been subject to a recall by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA).

2024 Mercedes-Benz EQE Sedan Performance Specifications

(Specs sourced from Mercedes-Benz & CarBuzz)

The recall involves a faulty fuse that "could lead to a sudden loss of power or critical safety functions," increasing the risk of a crash or injury. Since Consumer Reports gathers reliability information through owner surveys, they are unable to provide detailed data for the 2024 Mercedes-Benz EQE. Their surveys require a minimum of 200-400 responses per model year to ensure statistically significant results. As the EQE is a new model, Consumer Reports hasn't yet received enough surveys from owners to provide reliable data on its performance.

14 2024 Mercedes-Benz EQS SUV - 58/100

Starting Price: $104,400

Consumer Reports positions the 2024 Mercedes-Benz EQS SUV as the top contender in the very limited segment of 3-row electric SUVs with an overall score of 58. According to Consumer Reports, the EQS SUV boasts several strengths. It delivers a luxurious driving experience with impressive acceleration, a quiet cabin, and comfortable seating, especially for passengers in the first two rows. The optional third-row seating offers additional versatility, which is a rarity among electric SUVs. Consumer Reports acknowledges the high-quality materials used throughout the cabin.

2024 Mercedes-Benz EQS SUV Performance Specifications

(Specs sourced from Mercedes-Benz & CarBuzz)

Key Metrics

• Road Test: 83 out of 100
• Predicted Reliability: 23 out of 100

However, Consumer Reports also identifies some drawbacks that may be significant for potential buyers. One of the key concerns is the driving experience. While Consumer Reports acknowledges the car's power and quietness, they criticize the spongy-feeling brake pedal and confusing controls. Similar to the 2024 Mercedes-Benz EQE, Consumer Reports lacks sufficient data to provide detailed reliability information for the 2024 EQS SUV. Their surveys, designed to ensure statistically significant results, require a minimum of 200-400 responses per model year. Consumer Report is yet to receive enough owner surveys to offer reliable data. However, unlike the EQE, the NHTSA has not issued any recalls for the EQS SUV so far.

15 2024 Volkswagen ID.4 - 57/100

Starting Price: $39,590

Consumer Reports positions the 2024 Volkswagen ID.4 in seventh place out of seven electric SUVs they tested. The ID.4 received an overall score of 57 out of 100. According to Consumer Reports, the ID.4 offers some positive attributes. It delivers a pleasant driving experience with good acceleration, a quiet cabin, and a roomy interior for its size. Consumer Reports also highlights the ID.4's competitive pricing when compared to other electric SUVs. Notably, the all-wheel-drive ID.4 boasts an EPA-estimated driving range of 263 miles for 2024, making it a compelling option for many drivers.

2024 Volkswagen ID.4 Performance Specifications

(Specs sourced from Volkswagen)

Key Metrics

• Road Test: 78 out of 100
• Predicted Reliability: 29 out of 100
• Predicted Owner Satisfaction: 2 out of 5

However, Consumer Reports also identifies some drawbacks that may be significant for potential buyers. A major point of criticism is the unintuitive control system, which Consumer Reports feels detracts from the overall experience. Additionally, the brake pedal feel is considered below average.

Owner Satisfaction Ratings

• Driving Experience: 87 out of 100
• Comfort: 82 out of 100
• Value: 47 out of 100